When has negotiating with Israel ever helped the Palestinians?

Readers React
Netanyahu has a face that’s begging to be slapped and powerfully punched

To the editor: Danny Danon, Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations, writes that “the modern history of Israeli-Arab peace-making has taught us that only direct negotiations between the two sides can actually achieve results.” (“Israel’s U.N. ambassador: Direct diplomacy is the only way to peace,” Opinion, April 25)

Exactly the opposite is true. Past peace “processes” have resulted in Israel confiscating even more Palestinian land. Nothing positive has ever happened for Palestinians.

Yes, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has “extended himself … in his pursuit of direct negotiations with the Palestinian Authority,” but he has also said that he would never allow a Palestinian state. So what is the point of negotiations except to pretend that something positive is being done?

Palestinians would be insane to subject themselves to yet another peace “process.” Their only hope appears to be with the United Nations and the success of the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) initiative.

And why does Danon refer to “Israeli-Arab” negotiations instead of Israeli-Palestinian negotiations? Palestinians are, for the most part, an Arab people, but they are a separate people who have inhabited Palestine for many centuries and have hopes and aspirations of their own apart from other Arab countries…

To the editor: Danon blames Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas for the failure to hold more peace talks. But he curiously neglects to mention the rapid growth in Jewish-only, illegal settlements under Netanyahu.

When Israel carves out more and more land from the West Bank for Jewish-only developments, how can anyone believe its government is serious about allowing for a Palestinian state?

No wonder Abbas and supporters of Palestinian rights have turned to the BDS movement to pressure Israel to abide by international law.

Mandy Erickson, San Mateo, Calif. 

Follow the Opinion section on Twitter@latimesopinion and Facebook

Defining political issue of our time

NYU grad student union overwhelmingly votes to boycott Israel over violations of Palestinian human rights

NYU Graduate Student Organizing Committee is first private university labor union to support BDS, as movement grows

TOPICS: BDS, BOYCOTT DIVESTMENT SANCTIONS, ISRAEL, NEW YORK UNIVERSITY, PALESTINE, ,

"Defining political issue of our time": NYU grad student union overwhelmingly votes to boycott Israel over violations of Palestinian human rights(Credit: NYU GSOC)

Graduate students at New York University have overwhelmingly voted to boycott Israel in protest of its violation of Palestinian human rights.

Exactly two-thirds of voting members of the graduate student union the Graduate Student Organizing Committee, or GSOC-UAW 2110, supported a referendum on Friday that calls for New York University and United Auto Workers International to withdraw their investments from Israeli state institutions and international corporations complicit in violations of Palestinian human and civil rights.

At least 645 union members participated in the vote. An additional 57 percent of voting members pledged to uphold the academic boycott of Israel, refraining from participating in research and academic programs sponsored by institutions funded by the Israeli government.

The union says this “was an unusually large membership turnout, a testament to union democracy.” It explained in a statement that the vote took place after a period of “vigorous debate and engagement with the union among wide layers of graduate workers.”

“After months of mass mobilization and a four-day election, GSOC members have taken a clear stand for justice in Palestine,” explained Shafeka Hashash, a member of the union’s Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions, or BDS, caucus.

“This historic endorsement of BDS by GSOC at NYU occurs in the wake of growing momentum for the movement across university campuses and labor unions nationwide,” she added.

BDS is an international grassroots movement that uses peaceful economic means to pressure Israel into complying with international law and respecting Palestinian human rights. The campaign was called for by Palestinian civil society and by major trade unions in the occupied Palestinian territories.

The Graduate Student Organizing Committee is a labor union representing more than 2,000 teaching assistants, adjunct instructors, research assistants and other graduate workers at New York University, or NYU. It is the first recognized graduate worker union at a private university in the U.S.

The union says its referendum vote it sets “an important precedent for both solidarity with Palestine and for union democracy.”

“In addition to bringing material gains for their members, NYU graduate students are reclaiming the union as a political platform for social justice causes,” explained Maya Wind, an Israeli activist and Ph.D. student at NYU who is a member of the union.

“Through the recent mass mobilization for justice in Palestine we have taken a stand on one of the defining political issues of our time,” she added. “The referendum success is indicative of the traction the movement is gaining across university campuses, and increasingly among graduate students.”

The referendum also calls on NYU to close its sister program in Israel’s Tel Aviv University, which the union says violates its own non-discrimination policy.

A recent U.S. State Department report acknowledged the “institutional and societal discrimination against Arab citizens of Israel,” as well as the unlawful killings, excessive force and torture people endure at the hands of the Israeli military in the illegally occupied Palestinian territories.

Students of NYU and other universities around the country, we solute you for being humanitarians and calling for BDS of Israel. The Israelis have long lied to us and forced us to believe that the Palestinians are terrorists when in fact they are the ones who are spreading terror in the Palestine, robbing people of their land and resources and killing innocent men, women and children.

BERNIE SANDERS ACCUSED OF ‘BLOOD LIBEL’ OVER WRONG GAZA CASUALTY FIGURES

BY

Sanders Israel Gaza
Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders speaks at a rally at Temple University in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, April 6, 2016. Sanders incorrectly estimated that the Israeli military killed 10,000 Palestinian civilians in the Gaza conflict in 2014.JESSICA KOURKOUNIS/GETTY IMAGES

A former Israeli ambassador to the U.S. on Thursday accused U.S. Democratic candidate Bernie Sanders of the ancient “blood libel” smear used against Jews after he incorrectly stated that Israel had killed 10,000 Palestinian civilians in the 2014 Gaza conflict.

Michael Oren, now an Israeli lawmaker, criticized the socialist candidate and accused him of endangering Israel’s security with his comments in a recent interview with the New York Daily News in which the Vermont senator overestimated the Palestinian civilian death toll in Gaza by more than 8,000.

“First of all, he should get his facts right. Secondly, he owes Israel an apology,” Oren told The Times of Israel. “He accused us of a blood libel. He accused us of bombing hospitals. He accused us of killing 10,000 Palestinian civilians. Don’t you think that merits an apology?”

The Israeli military, in an operation named Operation Protective Edge, killed over 2,100 Palestinians—at least 1,585 civilians, of which 530 were children— according to U.N. and Palestinian accounts, and Palestinian militant groups killed 72 Israelis—all but five soldiers, according to Israeli accounts.

In a transcript of the interview with the New York daily, Sanders said that he cannot remember the figures off the top of his head then proceeds to use the incorrect number. “ I don’t remember the figures, but my recollection is over 10,000 innocent people were killed in Gaza. Does that sound right?”

He added: “I don’t have it in my number… but I think it’s over 10,000. My understanding is that a whole lot of apartment houses were leveled. Hospitals, I think, were bombed. So yeah, I do believe and I don’t think I’m alone in believing that Israel’s force was more indiscriminate than it should have been.”

The Israeli military entered into the coastal enclave controlled by Palestinian militant group Hamas to prevent Palestinian rocket fire into Israeli territory and an extensive tunnel network used for smuggling and cross-border attacks against Israeli targets.

Oren said that Sanders’ claim that Israel had bombed hospitals was untrue. The Israeli military did however conduct air strikes on the Al-Wafa hospital in Gaza during the conflict, saying that it had been used as a base for Hamas militants to conduct attacks on Israeli forces.

Bernie Sanders is one of many Jews around the world who have conscious and good common sense. He does not praise Israel for the heinous crimes they commit on daily bases. He does not try to justify their barbaric actions against the Palestinians but condemns them, and that’s what the Israelis hate more than anything. They want people to kiss their ass and praise them for whatever they do like Ted Cruz and many other scum bags like him, and when they see a Jew speaking his mind and tells as it is, they go crazy. Bernie Sanders is not one they like or support because he has  conscious and integrity. That’s why he is gaining momentum and winning against the Israeli’s puppet Hillary Clinton.

Israel tears down seven Palestinian homes in 24 hours

Homes belonging to Palestinians accused of targeting Israelis have been razed in Occupied West Bank, leading to clashes.

Since the beginning of this year, Israel has demolished on average 29 Palestinian-owned buildings a week, according to the UN [Filepic: EPA]
Since the beginning of this year, Israel has demolished on average 29 Palestinian-owned buildings a week, according to the UN [Filepic: EPA]

Ramallah, Occupied West Bank – Seven Palestinian homes have been demolished in the past 24 hours across the Occupied West Bank – a move dubbed by Palestinian leaders as “collective punishment”.

The list of demolished structures includes three houses in Qabatiya town south of Jenin belonging to families of a trio gunned down in February after they killed an Israeli soldier.

Overnight on Monday, Israeli forces destroyed the family homes of Ahmad Zakarneh, Mohammad Kmeel and Ahmad Abu el-Rub, who fatally shot an Israeli border policewoman near Jerusalem’s Damascus Gate.

Four other homes were also razed in the Occupied East Jerusalem and villages of Surif and Duma in West Bank.

Palestinians cry foul over house demolitions

Clashes erupted in Qabatiya following the demolitions, with five Palestinians taken to hospital in Jenin after they were shot with rubber-coated steel bullets.

The family of a fourth man – incarcerated by Israel following accusations of aiding the three young men – was also handed a demolition order.

Qabatiya, home to 20,000 Palestinians, has been completely sealed off by the Israeli army twice in recent months, and many of its inhabitants have had their work permits revoked.

Since the beginning of 2016, Israel has demolished, on average, 29 Palestinian-owned buildings a week, according to the UN [EPA]

At least 10 Palestinians from the town have also been killed by Israeli forces since October last year.

In a wave of attacks since October last year – carried mostly by young, disgruntled Palestinian youths – at least 33 Israelis and foreign nationals have died.

Nearly 200 Palestinians, including civilians, assailants and others whom Israeli officials claim were armed with knives, have been killed.

Since September last year, 57 houses belonging to Palestinians have been levelled, according to the Palestine Liberation Organisation’s negotiations affairs department.


READ MORE: How impunity defines Israel and victimises Palestinians


Israel halted the punitive practice it regularly uses against Palestinians in 2005 after an internal commission found that it did not deter attacks. But the policy was revived last year despite the recommendations, and slammed by rights groups as a form of collective punishment.

“This is an arbitrary policy that affects everyone indiscriminately,” said Ahmad Kmeel, Mohammad’s father. “How is [it] the fault of the father, mother and the children? No one knew what he was going to do.”

Israel’s Supreme Court paved the way for the demolitions after it turned down appeals made on behalf of the families. Rajeh Zakarneh, Ahmad’s father, said the family dismantled and moved furniture after losing the petition.

“I built this house with my own two hands,” Zakarneh told Al Jazeera. “But my son is worth more than a thousand homes.”

Israeli settlement in the E1 corridor would connect Jerusalem to a large settlement bloc in West Bank [File: Rich Wiles/Al Jazeera]

Earlier on Sunday, the court had cancelled home-demolition orders for three of four Palestinians convicted of being involved in a stone-throwing attack in September that led to the death of an Israeli motorist. Najeh Abu el-Rub, Ahmad’s father, had hoped the court would also overturn the decision to raze his family home.

“We turned to the courts but that did nothing for us. They insisted on destroying the houses,” Abu el-Rub said.

Chief Palestinian negotiator Sa’eb Erekat said the house demolitions were tantamount to acts of “collective punishment” that were being reported to the International Criminal Court.

“Granting impunity for continued Israeli crimes will not achieve a resumption of negotiations. Rather, it is killing any realistic political horizon to end the Israeli occupation of the State of Palestine,” Erekat said.

Israel ramps up demolitions of Palestinian structures

UN figures show the destruction of homes in the occupied territories has tripled since January.

Israel says home demolitions are an effective tool to deter attacks, but critics say it's collective punishment [Nasser Shiyoukhi/AP]
Israel says home demolitions are an effective tool to deter attacks, but critics say it’s collective punishment [Nasser Shiyoukhi/AP]

The Israeli military has tripled its demolitions of Palestinian-owned structures in the occupied territories over the past three months, a United Nations’ report says.

Figures collated by the UN’s office for the coordination of humanitarian affairs (OCHA) – which operates in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem – show from an average of 50 demolitions a month in 2012-2015, the number rose to 165 since January, with 235 demolitions in February alone.

On Thursday, Israeli authorities demolished Palestinian buildings in al-Khan al-Ahmar village near the West Bank city of Jericho, and in Khirbet Tana village near Nablus.

 Inside Story – Punishing the Palestinians

One of the owners of the demolished structures in al-Khan al-Ahmar, Hussein Kaabneh, said the demolition team came in the morning without warning.

“I was surprised by the police and army … so I was very mad. I asked them, ‘Why do you want to demolish it?’ I did not get a warning or anything. And he told me, ‘you are [your structure is] not legal’,” Kaabneh told Reuters news agency.

The Israeli military, which has occupied the West Bank since the 1967 Middle East war, says it carries out the demolitions because the structures are illegal: either built without a permit, in a closed military area or firing zone, or violate other planning and zoning restrictions.

The UN and rights groups point out that permits are almost impossible for Palestinians to acquire, that firing zones are often declared but seldom used, and many planning restrictions date from the British Mandate in the 1930s.

The UN report on demolitions has alarmed diplomats and human rights groups over what they regard as a sustained violation of international law.

“It is a very marked and worrying increase,” said Catherine Cook, an OCHA official based in Jerusalem who closely monitors the demolitions, describing the situation as the worst since the UN body started collecting figures in 2009.

“The hardest hit are Bedouin and Palestinian farming communities who are at risk of forcible transfer, which is a clear violation of international law,” she said.


READ MORE: Israel demolishes Palestinian-owned homes in West Bank


The demolished structures include houses, Bedouin tents, livestock pens, outhouses and schools. In an increasing number of cases, it also includes humanitarian buildings erected by the European Union to help those affected by earlier demolitions.

Appearing before a sub-committee in the Israeli parliament on Wednesday, Major-General Yoav Mordechai – coordinator of the Israeli government’s activities in the West Bank – defended the demolition policy and told politicians he was doing all he could to carry out 11,000 outstanding destruction orders.

 Israel begins demolishing homes over attacks

The politicians summoned Mordechai to the hearing because of concerns he is not doing enough to dismantle Palestinian structures, and focusing instead on removing unauthorised Israeli construction in the West Bank.

“I want to state unequivocally that enforcement is more severe towards the Palestinians,” Mordechai told them.

“Moreover, much of the enforcement with regard to the Palestinians takes place on private Palestinian land.”

According to B’Tselem, an Israeli human rights group, Mordechai’s admission appears to confirm that Israel’s policy discriminates against Palestinians.

“There is undoubtedly a wave of demolitions and displacements that is severely threatening the ability of thousands of Palestinians to live in these areas,” said Sarit Michaeli, the spokeswoman for B’Tselem.

“To demolish the homes of Palestinians who are protected under the Geneva Conventions and to build [Israeli] settlements is a clear violation of international humanitarian law,” she said.


READ MORE: Israel tears down seven Palestinian homes in 24 hours


Last month, the European Union hit out at Israeli authorities after a school funded by the French government was demolished.

In the West Bank, an estimated 18 percent of the area has been declared by Israeli authorities as “firing zones”, and 38 Palestinian communities are located within these areas.

Because the Israeli civil administration prohibits building in these areas, wide-scale demolitions frequently take place.

Throughout occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem, some 90,000 Palestinians are facing potential displacement, according to OCHA.

How in the world can anyone with a particle of Conscience justify the demolishing of the Palestinians’ home? What kind of animals do this? If that’s not the worst crime against humanity, I don’t know what is!! What is our government do about this? we give the Israelis more munitions to do more!! and we call ourselves HUMAN RIGHTS ADVOCATES. what a joke!!

 ‘Collective punishment’ targets Palestinians